Fantasy Football Trade Analyzer Enter the names here, one by one, of the fantasy football players involved in the trade and then click or tab the name when you see it. 1. Enter the player(s) you are trading away 2. Enter the player(s) that you are getting in the trade Now updated for the 2015-2016 season! Please share this tool with your friends Let us know what you think about this fantasy football tool by entering a comment. How was the fantasy football trade analysis ? 134 Comments Join the Conversation → nice tool, I think I have the perfect team now. thanks! zheng / September 21, 2011 Thank you for this, I was looking around for a good trade analyzer for a long time. eric / September 21, 2011 awesome David / September 21, 2011 This is really going to help me with some tough trades. Carlos / September 22, 2011 Nice Would be great to be able to input scoring system, PPR v Standard, but great work! Thanks Pablo / September 27, 2011 pretty good, def want some more info tho. ty nizzie / September 27, 2011 Thank you, I really appreciate the feedback. I will definitely try to improve this tool with these features. Admin / September 28, 2011 I agree as far as the qb situation – I was thinking about getting Matt Hasselbeck or Jason Campbell off waivers – Do you think that will suffice? I think i’ll play around with the second option since Fred Jackson has been hot for me so far – I do really need the WR depth though John / October 2, 2011 I would go with Matt Hasselbeck, he’s a decent backup, although Kenny Britt’s injury will hurt his number. Try this one: Larry Fitzgerald and Jordy Nelson for Matt Ryan and Legarrette Blount Admin / October 2, 2011 Would you do either of these trades? Legarrette Blount and Percy Harvin for Tony Romo and Tim Hightower (I need a QB bad…and have Lesean McCoy, MJD and Steven Jackson at RB already). Or…. Legarrette Blount and Sam Bradford for Eli Manning at Nate Washington? Swoosh / October 4, 2011 I would go with: (trading) Legarrette Blount and Percy Harvin for (getting) Tony Romo and Tim Hightower Admin / October 4, 2011 Thanks for the advice! Swoosh / October 4, 2011 You’re welcome! Admin / October 4, 2011 I am pretty loaded at rb and was wanting to unload some to get better at wr position. Which rbs should i keep(trying to keep 3) and which ones should I trade? qbs romo and sanchez rbs felix best ingram hightower rice wrs fitz v jackson nate washington mike thomas te winslow dst redskins I have a guy in my league willing to trade desean jackson but he only has 3 wrs and would want a rb and wr in the deal. What kind of deal should I try with him? Would felix and washington or hightower and washington be too much for desean? Thanks for the help in advance! TexasMade / October 5, 2011 I would try to set up the following trade: Tim Hightower and Nate Washington for DeSean Jackson Hightower’s value has decreased significantly over the last two weeks (injuries + Torain’s performance in week 4). While DeSean is still one of the top WR in the game. Admin / October 5, 2011 Very cool. Would like to see an EDIT THIS TRADE T / October 5, 2011 Schaub(Brees is my starter), Felix Jones and Jordy Nelson for Lesean McCoy? Coming4TheWin / October 5, 2011 It’s not that great of a trade for you, you are giving up quite a bit for McCoy. But Felix Jones has played rather poorly and you have Brees already. It’s borderline, but acceptable. Admin / October 5, 2011 Ok I have a waiver question for you. I’m looking at these guys for the season and the bye week QB – Jason Campbell, Tim Tebow RB – Jackie Battle, Marshawn Lynch WR – Pierre Garcon, Darius Hayward Bey, Steve Breaston D – 49ers (for the bye week and to spell the jets) My roster that I would be willing to drop is Julio Jones, Matt Ryan, Steven Ridley, Brandon Jacobs, Eric Decker, Sidney Rice Which moves do you make? John / October 11, 2011 Hi John, I would make the following moves based purely on value: I would pick-up: Pierre Garcon and Marshawn Lynch. Dropping: Sidney Rice and Brandon Jacobs. Pierre Garcon continues to rise on value, while Sidney Rice’s future is a bit shaky. Admin / October 11, 2011 (in reply to John) Im stacked at WR (R White, C Johnson, M. Austin, P. Harvin, F. Jones, S. Johnson). But I’m light at RB (Chris Johnson, J Best. T Hightower, L. Blount) Blount is hurt and Johnson is on a bye. Im in a standard league w/ a RB/WR flex. Should I trade Miles Austin for Michael Turner? turbo / October 12, 2011 Absolutely, Michael Turner should give you more points than Miles Austin, on average, as the number one RB in a strong offense. This trade looks good for you. Admin / October 12, 2011 PPR league I trade Rodgers and Mendenhall I get Ryan and McFadden I have Tebow as well thots? Pablo / October 12, 2011 Although McFadden is having a terrific season, Mendenhall should bounce back and have a good season after he gets healthy. The key to this trade is the large difference in value between Rodgers and M. Ryan. Rodgers is an elite QB, while M. Ryan is not nearly there yet. Reject this trade, you are giving up too much. Admin / October 12, 2011 (in reply to Pablo) What if I wanted to trade Dez Bryant and receive Beanie Wells 5th Round Pick Factoring in Draft Picks / October 13, 2011 I’m sorry, not Beanie Wells, Victor Cruz Factoring in Draft Picks / October 13, 2011 should i trade hakeem nicks darren mcfadden for calvin johnson shonn greene Anonymous / October 13, 2011 Factoring in Draft Picks, The analyzer doesn’t have the ability to calculate the value of a future 5th round pick, but that is a very interesting idea and I’ll try to include it in the future. One method that you can use would be to substitute the future 5th round pick for a player that you think would be drafted in that position. Admin / October 13, 2011 Anonymous, Absolutely not, the combined value of Darren Mcfadden and Hakeem Nicks is substantially higher than the value of Shonn Greene and Calvin Johnson. Let’s break down the trade: Hakeem Nicks vs Calvin Johnson Calvin Johnson’s value is higher than Hakeem Nicks’ value, but Nicks is still a top tier WR. The difference in value here isn’t large enough to justify the value overall trade. Darren Mcfadden vs Shonn Greene: Darren Mcfadden’s value is much higher than Shonn Greene’s value, it really isn’t close. LT is still handcuffing Shonn Greene, while Mcfadden dominates his backfield. Based on value, this is a bad trade for you. Admin / October 13, 2011 I already have Arron Rodgers with cam newton on the bench. Got offered deion branch and Ryan toraine for cam newton. What do you think? My WRs already are mike Wallace(pit), jermey maclin, lance Moore, mike thomas, Johnny Knox and Emanuel Saunders. My RBs are stephin Jackson, A. Bradshaw, and mark ingram. Any advice would be cool. BoRAT / October 13, 2011 This is not a good trade, you should be demanding more for Cam Newton. He’s a very promising QB with huge upside. Ryan Torain has a lot of competition with Tim Hightower and Roy Helu. The same can be said for D. Branch, he’s barely a number two WR. Most of the targets are going to Wes Welker or the TEs. Admin / October 13, 2011 What about Deshawn Jackson and Cedric benson for Cam? BoRAT / October 13, 2011 That’s a much better trade for you. Go for it. Admin / October 13, 2011 I need RBs. Do you think I should trade Drew Brees for Matt Schaub and Frank Gore at this point in the season? Sean / October 14, 2011 Yes, specially if you are in need of a solid RB. But keep in mind, Frank Gore does have an extensive history of getting hurt. Go for it. Admin / October 14, 2011 (in reply to Sean) How about Miles Austin for Maurice Jones-Drew? Sean / October 14, 2011 Yes, MJD is a powerhouse every year, even without a solid QB. Admin / October 14, 2011 I get Ravens D and Chris Johnson. (my current defense is the Patriots and my RB are Rice, Wells, Greene, Lynch. WR’s are V.Jax, Steve Johnson and Fitzgerald). He gets Beanie Wells and Stevie Johnson. (his current RB’s are Forte, C. Johnson, Green-Ellis. WR’s are Manningham and Sanders. Plus he has 49ers D as well.) I am not really looking for fairness but does it help my team a lot? My starters would Flacco, Rice, C. Johnson, Greene, V. Jax, Fitzgerald, Graham, Ravens D, Hanson. Nick / October 14, 2011 You have the huge potential of Chris Johnson in this trade, but it is a gamble. He is due for a comeback, but with the current QB situation and his preseason this might take a while. Also know that this does leave you a little thin on the WR position. It’s risky and it leaves you with some weaknesses, but given the reward this could be worth it. Admin / October 14, 2011 I get Vincent Jackson and give up Frank Gore (PPR scoring), I have RB: Foster, Gore, D. Thomas and at WR: Dez Bryant, B. Marshall & Jordy Nelson. Joe / October 14, 2011 No, that would be a bad trade for you. Frank Gore’s upside is a lot higher than Vincent Jackson, even in a ppr scoring system, in relation to their overall value. Admin / October 14, 2011 Hello! Awesome site. I have two offers out there I am considering, both involve me giving up Cam Newton. First trade I give up Cam, Frank Gore and Steve Smith (CAR) for Arian Foster, Josh Freeman, and AJ Green. Second deal I give up Cam, Shonn Greene and Steve Smith for Matt Ryan, Chris Johnson and Stevie Johnson. Should I consider either Deal? JEFF / October 14, 2011 I thought I made a good trade, but the trade machine says no. I get LeSean McCoy and James Jones for Megatron and Mark Ingram. Ingram is in a RBBC at best. Did I mess up? Here’s the rest of my team: QB – Fitzpatrick, Kolb RB – LeSean, Best, Felix Jones, Bush, Spiller WR – Andre Johnson, Marshall, Garcon, Jones, Baldwin, Simpson We start 1QB, 2 RB, 2 WR and a flex Mark / October 14, 2011 Hi Jeff, Thank you, I am glad you like the website! The evaluation favors the second trade, mostly because: a) You are getting Stevie Johnson instead of A.J. Green. A.J. Green is a phenomenal rookie, but Stevie Johnson is the #1 WR in an offense that features Ryan Fitzpatrick as the QB, which is a significant upgrade from the situation at CIN. b) You are giving up Shonn Greene instead of Frank Gore. Frank Gore has almost no competition in an offense that relies on him, while Shonn Greene has to compete with LT. Admin / October 14, 2011 Hi Mark, The issue is that Calvin Johnson’s value is very close to LeSean McCoy. The difference, and this is what makes this a less-than-optimal trade for you, is that Ingram has a higher value than James Jones. Even in NO and as a RBBC, he’s still getting a significant amount of touches and his upside is huge. The same can’t really be said about James Jones, who is barely the third option in the passing game for GB. But don’t worry, you got an extremely good RB, which is very very important. Admin / October 14, 2011 Cool Site… I have an offer for me to give up Matthew Stafford and Stevie Johnson and I receive Jay Cutler and Larry Fitzgerald. My other QB as of now is Tim Tebow which I would plan to play. We are in a 10 team PPR league. The rest of my team ia as follows and we play 1QB-2RB-2WR-1FLEX-1TE: Matthew Stafford Tim Tebow Ahmad Bradshaw Tim Hightower Felix Jones James Starks Marshawn Lynch Roddy White Hakeem nicks Stevie Johnson Antonio Brown Aaron Hernandez Brandon Pettigrew Should I pull the trigger? WchMeGo / October 15, 2011 You are trading away a very good QB in Matthew Stafford. He could be a top ten QBs by the end of the year if he can stay healthy. Having said that, Larry Fitzgerald is still an extremely good WR that can be a deadly weapon in a PPR league if he starts clicking with Kevin Kolb. Overall, this looks like an ok trade for you, but it does leave you thin at the QB position. Admin / October 15, 2011 I have Vernon Davis and picked up Gates off waivers and the guy said he didn’t mean to drop him. Is traded him back Gates for Mike Williams Tampa Bay a fair trade since I already have Davis. My recievers are Garcon, Maclin, Heyward Bay and Greg Little. Non PPR league starting 3 recievers Scott / October 17, 2011 I would say yes, because Mike Williams is the number one WR in TB. He should bounce back. Admin / October 17, 2011 Thanks, I was thinking that also Scott / October 17, 2011 I’m in a 14 team league where talent is thin. It’s a keeper leauge where we keep 3 players. As of now my keepers would be Rivers, Mathews and Dwayne Bowe (or possibly Shonn Greene). I’m 4-2 and looking decent. The last place team is looking for a possibly better keeper. He’s offered me Reggie Wayne for Brandon Lloyd. I’m not sure what to do with Lloyd now in St. Louis. Reggie isn’t going to be great with Curtis Painter but he should be consistent. Should I take the deal? My team is: Rivers Bowe Santana Moss Victor Cruz Brandon Llyod Shonn Greene Ryan Mathews Owen Daniels Ryan Grant Massoquoi DeMarco Murray. Help please! Joshua / October 19, 2011 Stick with Reggie. Brandon Lloyd has Sam Bradford, a young and talented QB, but it should take some time for the chemistry between them to develop and they can put up some strong fantasy points. Reggie Wayne was a top tier WR last year, but without Peyton Manning his value has dropped significantly. Having said that, he is still an extremely talented player that should outperform Brandon Lloyd this year. Good luck! Admin / October 19, 2011 I have Ray Rice, Willis McGahee, Mike Tolbert and picked up Battle off waivers. If I’m looking to move Tolbert, what level of WR (where I could really use some help) should I expect to receive/target? Or should I look to move McGahee or Battle instead? Thanks for the great tool, very nice app here! would be nice to see some more numbers to know what the decision is based upon, but still a very nifty tool. Thanks! Justin / October 19, 2011 Thanks, Justin. I am extremely busy, but creating the second version of this tool is something that I definitely want to do. Hopefully I can find the time to do this before the end of the season. Trading Tolbert sounds good, most back-up RBs have very unstable fantasy value. Sticking with a starter is almost always the right choice. Since RBs are at a premium in your league, I would target WRs with a slightly larger value. For example: Jordy Nelson Brandon Marshall Eric Decker Admin / October 19, 2011 I am in a ppr league and I am currently in a world of hurt. I have been offered Shonn Greene and Doug Baldwin for Eric Decker. Alex / October 19, 2011 Hi Alex, Good trade, go for it. Doug Baldwin has started to click with his QB, but he is still a number two WR in a weak offense. Shoon Greene is the number one RB in his team, but LT continues to handcuff him. Eric Decker’s value really depends on how well Tim Tebow performs. But he is poised to become the number one WR in Denver. He could put up some very solid numbers. Admin / October 19, 2011 Very Nice…I really wish you had a PPR version. So I will just type my question. Owen Daniels & DeMarco Murray for Jordy Nelson or Larry Fitz Gerald My backup is Fred Davis…My Rbs are fine…and wanting to upgrade my WRs… J. / October 19, 2011 Hi J., A PPR version will be added in the future. This is a good trade for you. Jordy Nelson is performing very well, but Larry Fitzgerald is simply an elite WR. If you make this deal then try to get Larry Fitzgerald. Admin / October 19, 2011 so i have a deal that i am a little nervous about.. i give matt forte, and i get lesean mccoy and a.j green. the thing is–forte is having a incredible season and i feel like mccoy is risky and aj green is a rookie and i cant trust a rookie as much as i would like too. here is my team, just so you can see the depth.. QB Matthew Stafford, Det QB RB Matt Forte, Chi RB RB Arian Foster, Hou RB RB/WR: Brandon Marshall, Mia WR WR Roddy White, Atl WR WR Eric Decker, Den WR TE Jermichael Finley, GB TE D/ST Lions D/ST D/ST K: Mason Crosby, GB K BENCH: Matt Schaub Ryan Torain, Wsh RB Jordy Nelson, GB WR Julio Jones, Atl WR Jermaine Gresham, Cin TE Frank Gore Redskins D/ST jordan / October 19, 2011 It’s worth the risk. Matt Forte is essentially the CHI offense and is having a great season, but LeSean McCoy is having an even stronger season in the potent PHI offense. Plus you are receiving A.J. Green. This rookie is developing into a strong WR and the go to guy in CIN. If Andy Dalton stays healthy then A.J. Green should have a good year. It’s a good trade for you, but I like the fact that you are thinking it over before you make a decision. Admin / October 20, 2011 yeah, thanks so much! this is such a big help! ill be coming back and asking you many more questions! thanks so much! jordan / October 20, 2011 Thank you, jordan. I am glad I could help. Admin / October 20, 2011 So since Daniel Thomas is going to split carries I think i might move him out of my starting lineup. That means I’ll have to move either DHB or Julio Jones to flex. What do you think? Or should I pick Little, Demarco Murray, or Baldwin up off of waivers? Also would you start Tebow or Matt Ryan at QB? John / October 20, 2011 Just was offered: Bowe and Hasselbeck For Stafford and Decker Have Eli on bench as well as Megatron, Jennings and AJohnson hurt. Could have Bowe as Flex. Have Bradshaw and Freddy Jackson as RBs, and Battle, Hardesty and J Stewart as backups with upside. Hodge / October 20, 2011 Hi John, DHB is a little tricky since the QB situation is currently unclear. But he is trending upward. I hesitate to recommend him, but he is the best choice out the options that you presented. Out of Matt Ryan and Tebow, I would go with Matt Ryan simply because Tebow has yet to prove himself this year. He could have a big week, but it is more likely that he is still trying to get comfortable as the starting QB. Admin / October 20, 2011 Hi Hodge, I like this trade, go for it. Stafford’s value continues to rise in the up-and-coming DET offense, plus Decker could provide some strong numbers as the number one WR in DEN. But know that Stafford has a history of getting hurt, which adds some significant risk to this trade. Admin / October 20, 2011 I would be getting Hasselbeck and Bowe. So does this mean that I should NOT go ahead with this? The other team is throwing in a 2012 5th or 6th Round draft pick in our draft. I also have a follow-up trade to grab Tebow for Hasselbeck after this deal would go down, giving me Eli and Tebow to mix and match for the rest of the season while solidifying my FLEX position in a PPR league. Hodge / October 20, 2011 Thanks for the help – Also what do you think about a defense and kicker? I think it’s going to be a close game so right now I’m starting Jason Hanson and the Jets D – Do you think I should drop them and play the matchups with a guy like John Kasey or Matt Bryant at K and a D like the Cowboys or Bucs? John / October 20, 2011 Hi Hodge, Sorry about the mix-up. Correct under the previous setting I would advise you to reject the deal. But if you are getting a 5th round pick then deal is certainly much better for you. With that pick, assuming you have 12 teams in your league, you could easily pick up a strong TE or a solid number two WR. If that is the case then yes, go for it. Admin / October 20, 2011 Thanks for the help. I agree about the 5th Round Pick. We have 8 teams and we keep 3 players each season. Thanks again! Hodge / October 20, 2011 Hi John, I would think twice about starting any defense vs. SD. The Cowboys D might be a safer pick this week as they play STL. A kicker’s performance is difficult to predict, but try to go with Matt Bryant. He’s playing at home vs a defense that has given up plenty of points to Ks. Admin / October 20, 2011 No problem, Hodge. Good luck this year! Admin / October 20, 2011 I’m being offered S. Holmes and McGahee for MJD OR V. Jackson and McGahee for Forte. I’m leaning towards accepting the first option. What do you think, sir? Paul / October 21, 2011 Hi Paul, I agree, the current QB situation in JAX has really hurt MJD, while Forte continues to shine. You are getting a fair value for MJD in the trade, go for it. Admin / October 21, 2011 I’m stewing over a trade, and was wondering if you could help me out. Normally it’s a no brainer, but Romo’s got all his weapons back, and I really think he’s going to have a great finish to the year from here on out. The offer is this: Romo for Schaub Santonio Holmes I have megatron at wr, plus boldin but garbage after that. I’m deep at rb, but really need some help at wr. Holmes has been pretty useless this year, but the Jets always seem to turn it around. Any advice? Thanks hawker / October 22, 2011 Hi hawker, It’s a good deal, go for it. Schaub’s value isn’t too far away from Romo’s value once Andre Johnson returns from injury and Arian Foster gets it going again. Plus, Schaub is less injury-prone. Getting Santonio Holmes tips the trade in your favor, as he should be a solid flex/WR 3 player, but don’t expect top tier numbers from him. Admin / October 22, 2011 I’m looking to upgrade at qb. I have eli and ben but have been offered brady for steve smith and mike wallace . I will still have colston, marshall and aj green at wr.. Any thoughts Dan / October 22, 2011 Hi Dan, This move would deplete your depth in WRs in a significant way, don’t do it. Brady is a major upgrade for you, but you are giving up two WRs that are projected to end up in the top ten of WRs. My advise is to counter this trade with Mike Wallace and Marshall. Admin / October 22, 2011 I’ll give it a shot, thanks Dan / October 22, 2011 I just countered but if he rejects the idea the difference between starting Tom Brady Colston and Marshall Over Manning/Ben Smith and wallace On a weekly basis and he’s throwing in Desean Jackson who may not even start on my roster unless vic improves Dan / October 22, 2011 There’s a chance that he’s targeting a certain player like Steve Smith. If that’s the case then try to package a deal with Smith and Colston ( or Marshall) . Admin / October 22, 2011 I’m trading Maurice-Jones-Drew and Dwayne Bowe for Arian Foster and A.J Green. Was that a goo trade for me? Jake / October 22, 2011 Absolutely, Arian Foster is getting back into shape while A.J Green continues to rise as a legitimate number one WR. Maurice Jones-Drew’s value has dropped steadily due to the QB situation in JAX. Good trade. Admin / October 22, 2011 Thanks Jake / October 22, 2011 I’m thinking about trading Calvin Johnson and Steven Jackson for Matt Forte and Dez Bryant. Im not exactly sure if this would make my team better or worse? VV Here’s my team so you can have a better idea. QB Drew Brees RB Darren McFadden RB Steven Jackson RB/WR Darren Sproles WR Calvin Johnson WR Steve Smith WR Anquan Boldin TE Brandon Pettigrew D/ST Redskins D/ST Broncos K Billy Cundiff, Bal K Annie / October 22, 2011 Not a good trade, you are giving up too much. Matt Forte and Calvin Johnson cancel each other out in this trade as they are projected to have very strong numbers this year. What makes this a bad trade is that Steven Jackson’s value can surpass Dez Bryant’s value by a significant amount once Sam Bradford starts clicking with him again. Admin / October 22, 2011 Hi Jake, You’re welcome. Admin / October 22, 2011 What if i do Calvin Johnson and Anquan Boldin instead of Steven jackson? and also what would be a fair trade to get Wes Welker and Frank gore? who would i have to give to get them? it can be 2 for 1. Annie / October 22, 2011 Calvin Johnson and Anquan Boldin would be a better trade for you. Calvin Johnson and Steven Jackson would be fair for Wes Welker and Frank Gore. Admin / October 22, 2011 What good WR’s can i get for Darren Mcfadden & What good RB’s can i get for Calvin Johnson? (as fair as possible) Anonymous / October 22, 2011 There are plenty of combinations that would be fair for these players, but I will list a few. Mcfadden is an exceptional RB, so the only WR that could come close to his value (excluding Calvin Johnson) would be: Wes Welker You could also try some sort of package deal like: Vincent Jackson plus Dwayne Bowe For Calvin Johnson, a good RB would be: LeSean McCoy Adrian Peterson Or a combo like: Chris Wells plus LeGarrette Blount I hope that helps, try to play around with the analyzer for more combinations. Admin / October 22, 2011 Well he’s set on Smith and wallace Steve smith and mike wallace For Tom Brady and Hakim Nicks This let’s me drop Ben or Eli also to get depth somewhere. I appreciate your input thanks Dan / October 22, 2011 Also who would be the best pickup option for the rest of the year Hardesty Battle Or Deangelo williams Dan / October 22, 2011 I’m considering a trade: My Jeremy Maclin and Sam Bradford for his Matt Schaub. My only other QB is Carson Palmer. My other WRs are Calvin Johnson, Darrius Heyward-Bey, Nate Washington, Mario Manningham, and Greg Little. Justin / October 22, 2011 Hi Dan, Yes, Tom Brady and Hakeem Nicks is a much better trade for you, go for it. It’s hard to know if Battle will keep his job as the number one RB in KC. But I would pick him up based on his role as a starter and performance on week five. Admin / October 22, 2011 Hi Justin, Accept it if you are desperate for an upgrade at QB, but it’s not a good trade for you. Jeremy Maclin has some strong potential in the PHI offense and this move would leave you very thin at WR. Try to get a WR back in the trade. Admin / October 22, 2011 Would it be fair to give Calvin Johnson and Anquan Boldin for Ryan Mathews and Marques Colston? Anonymous / October 22, 2011 It’s close, but it would be slightly unfavorable for you. Admin / October 22, 2011 I really am desperate. I drafted Peyton Manning, and Sam Bradford to back him up. Bradford has been horrendous, so I picked up Grossman and he’s been filling in ever since, until he just got benched for Beck. So my options are either Curtis Painter or Carson Palmer. Neither looks particularly appetizing. Justin / October 22, 2011 I see, then go for it. Matt Schaub should fill in nicely. Admin / October 22, 2011 I traded Aaron Rodgers, Ryan Matthews, and Greg Jennings and I’m getting Calvin Johnson,Beanie Wells, and Drew Brees is that a good trade for me even trade or a really good trade for me Eli / October 22, 2011 In a 10 team dynasty league which has a 3 round rookie draft each year do you trade the following 4 away? Carson Palmer QB Adrian Peterson RB DeSean Jackson WR Kenny Britt WR FOR Cedric Benson RB Dwayne Bowe WR or Dez Bryant WR Matt Ryan QB BenJarvus Green-Ellis RB 2012 Draft, Rnd 1 Anonymous / October 22, 2011 Alright now I’m sitting with: Colston Nicks Marshall and Green At wr Benson/Forte/Mendenhall At rb Would like to package and get top rb or should I stick with depth and let it play out Dan / October 22, 2011 Hi Eli, I would say that it’s a good trade for you. But not really good. Admin / October 22, 2011 Hi Anonymous, No, you are trading away great young talent: an elite RB (Adrian Peterson) and two exceptional WRs (Kenny Britt and DeSean Jackson) without getting players of equal or greater value. BenJarvus Green-Ellis is a RB in NE, a team with a history of constantly switching up the starting RBs. His value could drop significantly in the near future. Cendric Benson’s potential value is shaky due to his off-the-field issues and status. Admin / October 22, 2011 Hi Dan, Stick with the depth, Mendenhall’s value should increase soon. Admin / October 22, 2011 Great tool and even better to see such a quick response from you with all these trade proposals. Any chance you can offer some advice to me? 10 team keeper league. Here’s my roster: QB Ryan/Eli RB Chris Johnson/Steven Jackson/Arian foster WR miles Austin/Dwayne bowe/victor Cruz/Brandon Lloyd TE Dallas Clark/Keller So would you trade Chris Johnson, Dallas Clark, Brandon Lloyd For Matt forte, jermichael Finley, Malcolm Floyd Thanks!!!! Chris M / October 22, 2011 Hi Chris M, Not a bad trade overall. Dallas Clark and Brandon Lloyd are both declining in value due to their respective QB situations. You are also getting an elite TE and RB in Finley and Forte. The only issue with this trade is the possibility of Chris Johnson having a strong bounce-back season next year. Also, Malcom Floyd will continue to be non-factor unless Vincent Jackson gets hurt. Thank you for the kind words, I am glad you like the tool. Admin / October 22, 2011 Would this be fair for me if i gave away Calvin Johnson and received Mike Wallace and Brandon Marshall? Anonymous / October 23, 2011 Hi Anonymous, It’s not great, but overall acceptable. Calvin Johnson is one of the best WRs this season, but you are getting decent depth at that position. Admin / October 23, 2011 Im trading welker/best and getting steve smith/vick…heres my current roster..good trade? Josh FreemanQB – Matt ForteRB – James StarksRB – Roddy WhiteWR – Kevin WalterWR – Jimmy GrahamTE – Maurice MorrisRB – Jahvid BestRB – LeSean McCoyRB – Knowshon MorenoRB – Jeremy MaclinWR – Robert MeachemWR – Wes Welker Taylor / October 23, 2011 Hi Taylor, It’s a good trade if Vick can stay healthy. There’s also a good chance that DET will reduce Best’s workload by a significant amount in the near future. Go for it. Admin / October 23, 2011 Here’s a trade that I’m considering offering after the MNF tonight, would you guys accept? TRADING – Miles Austin, Cam Newton, Maurice Jones-Drew, BenJarvus Green-Ellis RECIEVING – Calvin Johnson, Mark Sanchez, Frank Gore, DeAngelo Williams Daniel / October 24, 2011 Hi Daniel, You are getting Calvin Johnson, who is one of the best WR this season, but overall it’s not a great trade for you. Cam Newton is a top tier QB, certainly a much better fantasy choice than Mark Sanchez. Maurice Jones-Drew is declining in value, but is still a better choice than DeAngelo Williams, who is handcuffed by Jonathan Stewart. BenJarvus Green-Ellis is playing a key role in the strong NE offense, which has catapulted him to the top 10 in RBs. Admin / October 24, 2011 I need a answer to my trade, Getting Rashared Mendenhall giving Earnst Graham, and Shonne Green Eli / October 24, 2011 It’s a good trade for you, go for it. Admin / October 24, 2011 Im offering Nicks, Hillis, and A. Hernandez for M. Austin, Forte, and Gresham. Start 2 RBs, 2 WRs, TE and a Flex. I have B. Scott, B. Wells, and A. Foster at RB/Flex and Bowe & Harvin at WR. O. Daniels at TE. Trying to improve at RB. Is this a good deal for me? Wolfpack / October 25, 2011 Hi Wolfpack, If your main focus is to improve at RB then I would say go for it. You are getting a significant upgrade with Forte, who has played exceptionally this year. Admin / October 25, 2011 What about in terms of overall value? Is it relatively equal or am I getting the short end? Wolfpack / October 25, 2011 Hey, i was offered Tom Brady, Reggie Wayne and Willis Mcgahee for AJ green, Tim Tebow and Matt Forte… Non ppr league we start 2 rb, my other Rbs are MJD, Roy Helu and Mark Ingram. My other QB is Big Ben. seminole / October 25, 2011 my team now looks like this… non keeper qb- big ben, tim tebow rb- mjd, forte, ingram, helu wr- roddie white, aj green, steve smith (carolina) steve johnson, jordy nelson te- gates, pettigrew no flex, 2 rb 3 wrs seminole / October 25, 2011 Hi Wolfpack, In terms of overall, it’s roughly equal. Admin / October 25, 2011 Hi seminole, It’s an even trade. But, since you are very deep at the WR position, you should try to see if you can work a trade where you keep Forte and trade away another top WR. For example: AJ Green Roddie White Tim Tebow Admin / October 25, 2011 What do you think about trading Mathews, Torain, and Vincent Jackson for Arian Foster and Ben Tate My WB/RB/WR would then be WB: Rivers RB: L. Mccoy, A. Foster, L. Blount, B. Tate WR: C. Johnson, M. Colston, Mike Williams (TB), P. Burress, P Garcon. 2 RB, 2 WR, 1 flex, 12 team league. If that is too much for Foster, what do you think I should offer? Matt / October 25, 2011 I’m looking to deal for some combination of Tolbert, AJ Green, Jonathan Stewart, Peyton Hillis, Vernon Davis, or Ray Rice My roster that has trade value is Tebow, Fred Jackson, Run Dmc, Nicks, Mike Wallace, Greg Olsen, Daniel Thomas, Decker, Matty Ice, Mike Vick, DHB, and Julio Jones Can you assemble some sort of deal? John / October 25, 2011 Hi Matt, Arian Foster’s projected value is worth it, but you are still giving up a tad too much and it does leave you a little thin at the WR position. Try this deal: Trading Mathews, Torain, and Mike Williams (or P Garcon) Getting Arian Foster and Ben Tate Admin / October 25, 2011 Hi John, I currently have a full workload, try to assemble a trade and I can help you determine if the trade is good or bad for your team. Admin / October 25, 2011 Since i have Mcfadden on bye week 8 who should i start Pierre Garcon or Nate Washington? im guessing whoever has an easier matchup? But i still need a second point of view. & would it be fair for me to trade Anquan Boldin and receive Antonio Gates? or should i just keep my current TE which is Pettigrew? Anonymous / October 25, 2011 how this trade sound i give mendenhall mcfadden nicks and holmes i get mccoy jackson and wallace i have at rb ryan mattews and demarco murray still and at reciver i have dez bryant brandon lloyd and t.o. in case hes signed logan / October 25, 2011 Anonymous, Just based on the match-up I would go with Nate Washington. Now that DET has reduced Best’s workload, I would stick with Pettigrew for a week or two before making a trade. Admin / October 25, 2011 Hi logan, Really bad trade, you are giving up too much. Admin / October 25, 2011 Is this a good trade for me: TRADING A.J. Green Santana Moss James Starks FOR: Frank Gore Brandon Marshall PhillyPhan / October 25, 2011 Hi PhillyPhan, it’s a fairly even trade. Frank Gore has continued to put up strong numbers in SF and should continue this pattern. But, due to the current QB situation in MIA, you shouldn’t expect too much out of Marshall. Admin / October 25, 2011 Hello everybody, I am closing the comment section for a while to finish some upgrades in the website. Thank you for visiting this website, I really appreciate your comments and feedback. Admin / October 25, 2011 Comments are closed.